Welcome to Behind the Bookstore
"Behind the Bookstore" is a hidden gem in Edgartown, MA, blending the warmth of a cozy café with a vibrant dining experience. Nestled just behind a local bookstore, it offers an inviting ambiance enriched by the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and delightful treats. Guests can indulge in a variety of dishes, from the exquisite burrata to tantalizing halibut ceviche, all crafted with care. The friendly staff enhance the experience, offering personalized recommendations and showcasing local ingredients, such as fresh oysters and homemade pastries. Whether enjoying a leisurely breakfast or a delightful dinner, “Behind the Bookstore” promises comfort and culinary satisfaction, making it a must-visit destination.
-
46 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539, United States Hotline: +1 774-549-9123
Welcome to Behind the Bookstore, a charming haven located at 46 Main St, Edgartown, MA, where culinary artistry meets cozy ambiance. This unique restaurant encapsulates the heart of Martha's Vineyard, inviting guests to indulge in a delightful culinary experience tucked away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.
As you step inside, the surroundings enfold you in a warm embrace. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee dances in the air, harmonizing beautifully with the alluring scent of delectable dishes. Behind the Bookstore goes beyond just a dining location; it serves as a sanctuary for food lovers, bookworms, and anyone seeking a tranquil escape.
The menu is thoughtfully crafted, featuring a selection of enticing options that cater to various tastes. Start your journey with a Local Farm Salad ($19.00) or savor the flavors of the Halibut Ceviche ($21.00), which has garnered rave reviews from diners. If you're in the mood for sharing, don’t miss the Burrata dish or the freshly made bread—a choice highly praised by guests like 'S B', who emphasized the restaurant's ability to create a memorable dining experience through flavorful offerings.
- Toasts: Indulge in their sumptuous Italian Toast ($22.00) or Avocado Toast ($18.00), both of which have won hearts for their exquisite flavors and beautiful presentation.
- Starters: Enhance your meal with dishes such as Seared Sesame Tuna or Tomato Gazpacho ($14.00), perfect for igniting your palate.
- Raw Bar: For seafood aficionados, the Menemsha Spearpoint Oysters and Salmon Tartare are must-tries.
What sets Behind the Bookstore apart are not just the flavors, but also the stellar service. From friendly baristas who excel in crafting drinks to skilled staff like Taylor, the Oyster Shucker, who engages with guests, the commitment to customer satisfaction truly shines. Patrons like 'Grace Hagerty' have aptly described the place as “an absolute gem,” where every moment feels personal and warm.
And for those who prefer lighter bites or refreshing beverages, don't forget to try their homemade chai tea latte, an absolute delight during warm summer days. 'Sherry White' and 'Samantha Knight' both recommend the iced version—perfect while lounging in the shaded garden seating.
In conclusion, Behind the Bookstore is an unforgettable culinary retreat in Edgartown. Whether you're enjoying breakfast, lunch, or dinner, the dishes are crafted with care, making it a place to not only satisfy your hunger but also uplift your spirit. With a vibrant atmosphere that invites lingering over coffee and treats, it's a destination to relish, unwind, and create lasting memories. Make your reservation or stop by to discover why this spot is a favored choice for both locals and visitors alike.
For reservations or inquiries, reach out at +1 774-549-9123.
Wow! We really loved Behind the Bookstore as a dinner spot. The ambiance was so beautiful and the staff were incredibly friendly. Sam was our waiter - he was patient and made great recommendations for pairings. Taylor, the Oyster Shucker who is also a local - stopped by to ask about the Oysters. He was clearly a pro, and it was nice that he cared. Okay, now the important part: the food was just amazing!!! The Burrata dish, the freshly made bread, the Halibut ceviche, the squash soup … our table tried most of the menu in a shared style. It was worth it. Highly recommend this place.
They make their own chai! Get the iced chai tea latte. 6.75 Plenty of outdoor seating in a shaded garden.
Behind the Bookstore is an absolute gem tucked away in the heart of Edgartown. From the moment you step in, you're enveloped in a cozy atmosphere that feels like a warm hug. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee instantly captivates your senses, setting the stage for a delightful experience. The baristas here are true artisans, crafting each drink with precision and care. Whether you're a coffee connoisseur or just seeking a cozy spot to unwind, Behind the Bookstore has something for everyone. Their pastries are heavenly, perfectly complementing the rich, smooth brews. What truly sets this place apart is its ambiance; it's the perfect spot to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Whether you're catching up with friends, diving into a good book, or simply enjoying some me-time, Behind the Bookstore provides the perfect backdrop. Five stars without a doubt, for an experience that's as comforting as your favorite novel.
Great outdoor atmosphere! Out of the way- literally behind the bookstore! Matcha and chai lattes are very good…homemade (not the fake stuff). The Italian toast is amazing along with the avocado toast! They have gluten free buns which I used for my Italian toast. So yummy! A little pricey but it’s expected. They serve breakfast lunch and dinner -there’s a bar too. Will come again!
Loved coming here! Coffee was great and the bar had just opened, so we sat outside while it rained drinking and having a great time! One of the highlights of our trip!
If you’re ever at Martha’s Vineyard then I definitely recommend checking out this lovely little coffee shop! The coffee and food were delicious and the service was also fantastic! If you’re feeling adventurous then you might try the Saffron latte!
Such a delicious salad! Wish the protein options weren’t so expensive to add on but otherwise loved it. The corn muffin was also incredible. My friend loved her bowl as well :)
Our go-to place for lattes while vacationing in Edgartown! The staff and atmosphere are awesome. I recommend the vegan coffee cake, raspberry cruffin, or any croissant. If you get there at 7 am, all the pastries are hot out of the oven. Dinner is good too, but their specialty is great coffee.